Artikel Terkini

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV
Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV 3

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

There’s been a slew of electric vehicle previews and launches over the past few months, and the latest is the arrival of the Chery Omoda E5. Launched last week, the zero-emission version of the popular Omoda 5 is playing in the lower reaches of the electric SUV market, and there’s no prizes for guessing its biggest rival.

Indeed, the Omoda E5 is gunning straight for the BYD Atto 3, coming with an attractive price and some impressive specs. But Chery and BYD are not alone in this segment, as MG is also throwing its hat in the ring with the forthcoming ZS EV. Three value-driven EVs, each with its own strengths and weakness – read on to see how these cars stack up.

Price – ZS EV will be cheaper, Omoda E5 provides greater value

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

There’s a very definite order to the pricing of these cars, and the title of cheapest electric SUV in Malaysia will have to go to the ZS EV. It hasn’t been launched yet, but MG’s estimated pricing of RM129,000 puts it in a unique position, although – as you’ll find out soon enough – the low, low price does come with a fair share of tradeoffs.

But if it’s value for money you’re looking for, then the Omoda E5 has rather stolen the march from the Atto 3. Retailing at RM146,800, the Chery is a few thousand ringgit cheaper than the BYD in Standard Range form (RM149,800) – and that’s before you realise its specs are closer to the Atto 3 Extended Range (RM167,800). That’s a huge difference, whichever way you slice it.

Mind you, BYD has since responded by offering a massive RM20,000 rebate for 2023 model year Atto 3s, now starting from just RM129,800. That same rebate would put the Extended Range model right within the Omoda E5’s ballpark. Here are the prices of all four available models, sorted by price (all on-the-road without insurance):

  • MG ZS EV – RM129,000 (estimated)
  • Chery Omoda E5 – RM146,800
  • BYD Atto 3 Standard Range – RM149,800
  • BYD Atto 3 Extended Range – RM167,800
Dimensions – ZS EV smallest, Atto 3 most practical, with dedicated EV platform

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

Being in a different price bracket, it’s no surprise that the ZS EV is also smaller than the other two here, being classified as a B-segment rather than a C-segment SUV. Against the measuring tape, the MG is around 100 mm shorter and its wheelbase is also comfortably the smallest of the three. And yes, it uses torsion beam rear suspension instead of the multi-links employed by the Chery and BYD.

The more compact dimensions will likely result in a smaller cabin, especially at the back where the Atto 3 is particularly spacious thanks to having by far the longest wheelbase of them all. That’s the result of it being built on a bespoke EV platform, whereas the others were designed to fit petrol engines too.

But the ZS EV doesn’t have the smallest boot – in fact, it has the largest here, at 470 litres. The Atto 3 is next with a 440-litre boot, but the wooden spoon goes to the Omoda E5, the boot of which measures a scant 378 litres. It makes up for that by being the only one with a front boot.

Performance and range – Omoda 5 is the no-brainer

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

The Omoda E5’s true value proposition reveals itself when you look at the specs, where you’ll find striking similarities with the Atto 3 Extended Range. It makes the same amount of power and slightly more torque, and it also has a similarly-sized 61 kWh lithium iron phosphate (LFP) battery – also made by BYD, so one would assume it’s the same pack – as the Atto 3 ER variant. The Chery manages to eke out marginally more range (430 km versus 420 km on the WLTP cycle).

Next to the Chery, the MG’s specs look decidedly subpar. It has lower outputs and gets from zero to 100 km/h a trite slower as a result, but its Achilles’ heel has got to be its comparatively small 51.1 kWh battery. And even though it’s slightly larger than the one in the Atto 3 Standard Range, the car is clearly less efficient, as its range is a full 25 km shorter – a meagre 320 km.

One quirk of these three cars is that they all come with an LFP battery, instead of the more common nickel manganese cobalt (NMC) units. This should mean they’re safer, will last longer and support a higher amount of charge cycles, meaning you’ll be able to charge them more frequently before they degrade. Speaking of charging…

Charging – Omoda 5 takes the cake, ZS EV brings up the rear

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

See also  Polis buka kertas siasatan kes perlahankan laungan azan

Electric vehicles at the lower end of the price spectrum typically can’t support very fast charging speeds, and these cars are no exception. The fastest charging, the Omoda E5 and Atto 3 Extended Range, max out at 80 kW for DC power, so even these ones take quite a while to top up their batteries – 45 minutes from zero to 80% in the case of the BYD.

The Atto 3 Standard Range’s DC fast charging capacity is slightly lower at 70 kWh, but its smaller battery should cancel out that disadvantage. The most disappointing of the lot is the ZS EV, which can muster only 50 kW, so even charging its small battery from 10 to 80% takes a sluggish 54 minutes. That will be particularly costly at chargers that charge you by time spent.

All of these cars support just 7 kW single-phase AC charging, with the notable exception of the Omoda E5. It has a 9.9 kW three-phase onboard charger, so you will get the maximum charging speed available, no matter what type of wallbox you own.

Unfortunately, Chery doesn’t quote the AC charging time, but we can expect it to be slightly quicker than the Atto 3 Extended Range, which takes nine hours and 42 minutes for a full charge. As we’ve mentioned before, the downside of an EV with a 7 kW OBC is that the charging speed is halved to 3.5 kW if you use an 11 kW three-phase charger; you’ll need a 7 kW single-phase or 22 kW three-phase charger to get the full amount.

Warranty and maintenance – ZS EV provides longest coverage

Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV

Chery, MG and BYD all provide the longest warranty coverage in Malaysia, but the Omoda E5 and ZS EV offer a slight advantage in this regard, with a seven-year/150,000 km vehicle warranty. The Atto 3 is covered for six years, but with the same mileage cap.

The battery warranty, meanwhile, is eight years across the board, but the MG takes the lead when it comes to the mileage cap – 180,000 km versus 160,000 km for Chery and BYD. The latter also has a shorter eight-year/150,000 km warranty for the drive unit, inclusive of the motor.

One big draw for the Omoda E5 is that Chery offers a one-to-one replacement for the battery if its state of health drops below 70% while the car is still under warranty, no questions asked. It should be noted, however, that the BYD also has such a provision for a replacement battery (also with a state of health threshold of 70%) in its owner’s manual.

As for maintenance costs, none of the companies provide any service schedules or prices, although Chery does recommend a brake fluid service every 24 months or 40,000 km for the petrol-powered Omoda 5. However, BYD does offer various service packages to take care of you in its after-sales network throughout the duration of your ownership.

These include a Standard package that consists of the single-speed transmission oil servicing, air-con filter replacements and refrigerant servicing, brake fluid servicing and motor coolant servicing. This is priced at RM1,688 for three years, RM3,888 for six years and RM4,888 for eight years.

Alternatively, you can purchase a Plus package that throws in replacements for wipers, washer fluid, remote control and 12V batteries, and brake pads and discs. This is pretty costly, weighing in RM7,888 for six years and RM12,888 for eight years.

What else?

Clockwise from left: Chery Omoda E5, MG ZS EV, BYD Atto 3

As you can imagine, all cars on this list provide plenty of kit for your money. You get LED headlights, keyless entry, automatic air-con (single-zone for the MG, dual-zone for the rest), a powered driver’s seat, faux leather upholstery, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto connectivity, a Qi wireless charger, a 360-degree camera system, six airbags and a full complement of driver assists that include adaptive cruise control and lane centring assist.

Being a B-segment car, the ZS EV does lose out on a few features, such as a powered passenger seat and a powered tailgate; it also only has four speakers, which seems a little mean when the Omoda E5 has eight Sony-branded ones. On the flip side, it and the Atto 3 have a panoramic glass roof with a powered sunshade, whereas the Omoda E5 has a regular sunroof with a manual shade.

In terms of infotainment, the BYD takes the cake with its novel 12.8-inch rotating touchscreen, although the Chery’s fixed 12.3-inch display is hardly any smaller and the MG’s 10.1-inch display is still of a decent size. Better yet, the Chery and MG’s 12.3-inch digital instrument displays dwarf the BYD’s tiny five-inch readout.

See also  Shahrir Samad saman Tommy Thomas, Latheefa Koya, tuntut ganti rugi RM30j

Want to know how these cars drive? We have yet to sample the MG ZS EV, but you can check out Hafriz’s reviews of the Chery Omoda E5 and BYD Atto 3.

GALLERY: Chery Omoda E5 in Malaysia

GALLERY: MG ZS EV in Malaysia

GALLERY: BYD Atto 3 Extended Range in Malaysia

Looking to sell your car? Sell it with Carro.


Chery Omoda E5 v MG ZS EV v BYD Atto 3 Malaysian comparison – battle of the affordable electric SUV 3
kontraktor rumah
bina rumah
pinjaman lppsa
pengeluaran kwsp
spesifikasi rumah
rumah ibs
pelan rumah
rekabentuk rumah
bina rumah atas tanah sendiri
kontraktor rumah selangor
rumah banglo

Source

Kontraktor Bina Rumah IBS

LPPSA Kelayakan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Rumah Kontena Pinjaman LPPSA Rumah Pasang Siap Kontena Murah Rumah Kabin Buat Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Pinjamana Perumahan Kerajaan Loan LPPSA Untuk Beli Rumah Kelayakan LPPSA Rumah Kontena Pasang Siap Rumah Pasang Siap Malaysia Rumah IBS Malaysia Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Selangor LPPSA Loan Kontraktor Rumah Kontraktor Rumah IBS Kontraktor Rumah IBS Di Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Batang Kali‎ Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Klang‎ Kontraktor Bina Rumah di 16 Sierra, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Ampang Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Ara Damansara Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Balakong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Baru Bangi Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Baru Klang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Baru Selayang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Botanic Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Bukit Puchong 1, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Bukit Puchong 2, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Bukit Puchong, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Bukit Tinggi Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Country Homes Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar D’Alpinia, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Kinrara BK 1 Sehingga 6, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Mahkota Cheras Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Nusa Rhu Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Puchong Utama, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Puteri Puchong, Puchong Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Putra Permai Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Rasa Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Rinching Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Saujana Utama Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Seri Putra Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Sungai Buaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Sungai Long Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Sunway Semenyih Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Tasik Kesuma Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Teknologi Kajang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Teluk Datok Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar UtamaKontraktor Bina Rumah di Banting Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Batang Kali Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Batu 9 Cheras Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Batu Arang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bernam Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Antarabangsa Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Beruntung Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Gasing Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Komanwel Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Lanjan Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Raja Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit RimauKontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Sentosa Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Tagar Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bukit Tampoi Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Country Heights Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Damansara Damai Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Damansara Intan Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Damansara Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Damansara Perdana Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Damansara Utama Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Denai Alam Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Dengkil Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Dusun Tua Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Gombak SetiaKontraktor Bina Rumah di I-City Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kajang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kalumpang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kampung Jenderam Hilir Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kampung Kubu Gajah Dalam Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kelana Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kinrara Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Klang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kota Damansara Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kuala Kubu Bharu Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kuang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kwasa Damansara Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Lembah Beringin Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Mutiara Damansara Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Pandan Indah Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Pelabuhan Klang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Pinggiran Cyberjaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Puchong, Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Bandar Puteri Bangi Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Rawang, Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Sungai Rinching Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Sabak, Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Sekinchan Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Selayang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Semenyih Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Serendah Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Seri Kembangan Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Subang Bestari Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Subang Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Taman Tasik Semenyih Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Tanjung Sepat Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Teluk Datok Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Teluk Panglima Garang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Tropicana Kontraktor Bina Rumah di UEP Subang Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Ulu Yam Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Gombak Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Hulu Langat Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Hulu Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kuala Langat Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kuala Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Petaling Jaya Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Sabak Bernam Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Sepang Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Selangor Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kuala Lumpur Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Shah Alam Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Kapar Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Meru Kontraktor Bina Rumah di Puncak Alam Kontraktor Rumah Bina Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Pengeluaran Kwsp Spesifikasi Rumah Rumah IBS Pelan Rumah Rekabentuk Rumah Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kontraktor Rumah Selangor Rumah Banglo Kos Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Syarat Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri LPPSA Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kelantan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Sarawak Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kerajaan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Sabah Pinjaman Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kedah Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kelantan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Selangor Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kedah Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Johor Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Terengganu Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Perak Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Sarawak Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri MelakaBina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Negeri Sembilan Bantuan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kos Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Pinjaman Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Syarat Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri LPPSA Loan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Permohonan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Cara Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Skim Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri 2021 Pakej Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kelebihan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah SendiriBina Rumah Bawah 100k Kelantan Bina Rumah Sendiri Kos Bina Rumah 2022 Kos Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kelantan Pengalaman Buat Loan Untuk Bina Rumah Bina Rumah Murah Kontraktor Bina Rumah Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Bina Rumah Bajet 50k Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Selangor Bina Rumah Sendiri Tanpa Kontraktor Bina Rumah Bajet 30k Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kedah Bina Rumah Bajet 10k Bina Rumah Bajet 50k Selangor Bina Rumah SendiriBantuan Bina Rumah Atas Tanah SendiriKos Bina Rumah 2022Kos Bina Rumah 20×30 Pinjaman Bina Rumah Atas Tanah SendiriPengalaman Buat Loan Untuk Bina Rumah Kalkulator Bina Rumah Sendiri Pengeluaran Kwsp Untuk Bina Rumah Loan LPPSA Untuk Bina Rumah Kos Bina Rumah Bajet Kos Bina Rumah Kampung Bina Ayat Rumah Tangga Binatang Di Dinding Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Beli Tanah Pinjaman LPPSA Ubahsuai Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Beli Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Bina Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Untuk Beli Tanah Pinjaman LPPSA Untuk Bina Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Beli Tanah Pertanian Pinjaman LPPSA Jenis 5 Pinjaman LPPSA Atau Bank Semak Baki Pinjaman LPPSA Semakan Baki Pinjaman LPPSA Semak Baki Pinjaman LPPSA Sms Jenis Pinjaman LPPSA Syarat Pinjaman LPPSA Kelayakan Pinjaman LPPSA Jadual Kelayakan Pinjaman LPPSA Tuntutan Pindah Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Syarat Pinjaman LPPSA Bina Rumah Borang Tuntutan Pindah Rumah Pinjaman LPPSA Pinjaman Perumahan LPPSA Pinjaman Ubahsuai Rumah LPPSA Pinjaman Kedua LPPSA Pinjaman Kedua LPPSA Untuk Ubahsuai Rumah Pinjaman Perumahan LPPSA Vs Bank Pinjaman Bank Ke LPPSA Pinjaman Bersama LPPSA Pengiraan Kos Bina Rumah Sendiri Cara Jimat Buat Rumah Sendiri Bina Rumah Sendiri Tanpa Kontraktor Pengalaman Bina Rumah Sendiri Kos Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Sabah Pinjaman Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kerajaan Kos Bina Rumah 20×30 Kos Bina Rumah Paling Murah 2022 Harga Upah Tukang Rumah 2022 Kos Bina Rumah Kampung Kos Bina Rumah Bajet Anggaran Kos Bina Rumah 3 Bilik Kos Bina Rumah Atas Tanah Sendiri Kalkulator Bina Rumah Sendiri Rate Loan Rumah Kelayakan Loan Rumah Pinjaman Perumahan Public Bank Interest Bank Loan Rumah 2023 Interest Loan Rumah 2023 Berapa Lama Bank Proses Loan Rumah Cara Kira Interest Loan Rumah Bank Loan Rumah Terbaik Interest Bank Loan Rumah Public Bank Loan Rumah Affin Bank Loan Rumah Letter Offer Bank Loan Rumah Rhb Bank Loan Rumah Calculator Hong Leong Bank Loan Rumah Mbsb Bank Loan Rumah Rhb Bank Loan Rumah Cimb Bank Loan Rumah Agrobank Loan Rumah Bank Mana Senang Lulus Loan Rumah Bank Rakyat Loan Rumah Bank Islam Loan Rumah Bank Terbaik Untuk Loan Rumah Bank Call Untuk Pengesahan Loan Rumah Bank Muamalat Loan Rumah Bank Yang Mudah Lulus Loan Rumah Bank Akan Call Untuk Loan Rumah Bank Mbsb Loan Rumah Bank Islam Loan Rumah Contact Number LPPSA

See also  Shahrir Samad saman Tommy Thomas, Latheefa Koya, tuntut ganti rugi RM30j

See also  PM ingatkan pemimpin tidak ikut amalan penjajah punggah kekayaan negara